Top 10 Best Non Orange Self-Tanners in 2023

So, what is the orange coloration of the skin? You must have seen people with orange patches on their bodies. The real problem with the orange coloration is that this makes it obvious that you used a fake tan. Of course, you don’t want the people around you to know that you faked it. That’s why you need to avoid the situation.

What causes orange coloration? We can tell you 2 major reasons why this happens. First, the skin is thinner in certain parts of your body than in other areas. The skin on your elbows, feet, and knees is relatively thinner. That’s why oxidation is faster in those areas. The super-fast oxidation gives the orange coloration.

Another reason for orange coloration is dry skin. If you apply a self-tanner to dry skin, you’re increasing the chances of having orange skin. So, you must moisturize your skin before you apply your self-tanner. The good news is, there are several self-tanners that won’t give you orange skin. We will review some of them below.

Here are a few ways to avoid orange coloration. Make sure you exfoliate your skin before self-tanning. Furthermore, you need to apply a lotion on your elbows, feet, hands, and knees before applying a self-tanner to the areas.

It is also advisable to use a mitt or glove to apply the tanner to prevent uneven application. Also, stay away from tanners that are multiple shades darker than the natural color of your skin.

Top 10 Best Non Orange Self-Tanners:

1. Skinerals Californium Self-Tanner Mousse

The first thing that attracted us to this self-tanner is its anti-orange property. No matter how you apply it, you’ll never end up with orange patches on your body. Also, containing Shea butter, orange peel, and several minerals makes it highly nourishing to the skin. Apart from giving you a natural-looking tan, it will also smoothen and moisturize your skin.

The tanner gives a nice tan skin tone. It comes in a package with a dimension of 8.15 by 4.45 by 2.13 inches and a weight of 5.6 ounces. After applying it, the product lasts for up to 7 days before it starts fading. The tanner is 100 percent free of animal cruelty, offensive odor, sulfate, paraben, aerosol, streaks, and blotches.

It is able to reduce skin aging because it contains antioxidants. Finally, it is made in the United States, and it has an Amazon rating of 4.3 stars.  In our opinion, the self-tanner deserves the high rating.

2. b.tan Dark Self Tanner

This is another self-tanner that does not give an orange look. It comes in a package with the dimension of 8.3 by 2.2 by 2 inches, and it weighs 1.15 pounds. You can be sure that this formula dries very fast. Since it contains antioxidants and vitamin E, the tanner will smoothen your skin and reduce the aging process.

The tanning mousse comes with an application mitt, so you don’t need to squeeze out some dollars for a mitt. One of its biggest selling points is the duration of its tan. This mousse will last on your skin for up to 10 days. And it fades evenly. Since it also moisturizes the skin, it works wonders on dry skin.

The best part is that it gives zero streaks, zero blotches, and zero odor. In addition, we will recommend it for vegans because it is 100 percent cruelty-free. Overall, it has a current Amazon rating of 4.2 stars.

3. Skinerals Self-Tanner Extender Lotion

This is the second Skinerals tanner on our list, and it is an indication that the brand is a force to reckon with in the self-tanner industry. Like the other Skinerals tanner, this one will not also give orange coloration. You can use it for multiple skin tones – fair, medium, dark, very fair, and medium-dark.

Apart from tanning your skin, the product also moisturizes your skin. It comes with a dimension of 7.9 by 4.8 by 2.2 inches, and a weight of 8 ounces. When we tested it, we noticed that it does not give off any bad odor. It also gives zero blotches and streaks.

Furthermore, the product is cruelty-free, sulfate-free, paraben-free, and it is made in the United States. And the Amazon rating of the self-tanner is 4.0 stars.

4. Tanceuticals Self-Tanner – CC Self-Tanning Lotion

The fact that over 245,000 people use this product speaks volumes on its efficacy. And when we tested it, we found out why it has numerous users. The product gives all skin tones. Like the other tanners on this list, it does not give orange skin. With vitamin E among its ingredients, this product will also moisturize your skin.

It has a dimension of 1.5 by 2 by 7 inches and a weight of 5.6 ounces. While many other tanners have an offensive odor, this one gives off a nice scent. It is also easy to apply. Although it starts to fade after 7 days, it fades evenly and gracefully.

This product has a long list of no’s and you’ll love them. It has no paraben, no streaks, no orange coloration, no smell, no blotches, and no animal cruelty. This is why vegans and non-vegans will love it. The product is made in the United States.

Oh, we almost forgot to tell you that it comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee. Finally, it has an Amazon rating of 4.1 stars.

5. Miami Gorgeous Self-Tanning Mousse

This self-tanning mousse gives all skin tones. We noticed that it moisturizes the skin, smoothens it, and gives a natural-looking tan. The product has a dimension of 7 by 2 by 2 inches and a weight of 4.2 ounces. The quantity will give you about 10 to 12 full-body applications before it finishes.

This tanning mousse is one of the few that contains all of Vitamins A, C, D, and E. So, it is very nourishing to the skin. Also, it gives zero orange patches, zero gluten, zero streaks, zero odor, zero blotches, and it is 100 percent animal cruelty-free.

Other remarkable ingredients of the tanner are Elderflower extracts, Jojoba oil, Olive oil, coconut oil, and argan oil. In addition, it comes with a 100 percent money-back guarantee. It is made in the United States, and it has an Amazon rating of 4.3 stars.

6. Tan Physics True Color Sunless Tanner

This is a 2-in-1 self-tanner. It has a bronzer that gives a classic bronze tan and a booster that balances the pH level of the skin to fight the orange undertone. We found the product’s dimension to be 7 by 1 by 2 inches and a weight of 9.14 ounces.  The product replaces the common self-tanner with a refreshing fragrance.

In addition, the product also moisturizes the skin. We can tell you that it has zero gluten, zero parabens, and it will leave zero streaks and zero blotches on your skin. When you apply it to your skin, it dries very fast. Also, it is necessary to inform you that no animal was killed or hurt in the manufacture of the product.

The tanner lasts for about 5 to 6 days before it begins to fade evenly. Finally, it has an Amazon rating of 3.9 stars.

7. Dark Self-Tanning Lotion For Face And Body

This is another tanner that won’t give you orange patches. With its refreshing fragrance, you won’t need to cope with any offensive smell. When applied properly, it will leave no streaks and no blotches. And after 6 days, it will start fading uniformly. When we tried it, the product gave a deep skin tone.

Apart from giving you a natural-looking tan, it also moisturizes the skin. The pack comes with a dimension of 7.5 by 3 by 2 inches, and a weight of 3.84 ounces. It is easy to apply, and it comes with a 100 percent money-back guarantee.

We can assure you that it has no harsh chemical that may harm your skin. So, we guarantee its safety. Finally, it has a current Amazon rating of 3.9 stars.

8. Beauty by Earth Self-Tanner & Tanning Mitt Set

This tanner is in the big league of the tanners without orange streaks. And that’s why it made this list. The product is designed to give a deep skin tone. Apart from tanning you up, it will also nourish and moisturize your skin. The era of combining a self-tanner with a moisturizer is gradually going out as many new tanners now have the moisturizing ability.

This tanning lotion has a dimension of 10.43 by 7.68 by 3.54 inches with a weight of 15.2 ounces. The product contains Shea butter and Aloe Vera. So, you shouldn’t be surprised that it soothes the skin and reduces aging. The product does not have any foul smell and does not leave dark streaks or blotches.

When we tested it, the product didn’t stain our clothes, but we found a user that experienced otherwise. On the investigation of the incident, we found out that the user didn’t allow it to dry up before wearing her clothes. You need to give the product at least 15 minutes to dry up before you can wear your clothes. Furthermore, it is cruelty-free and has an Amazon rating of 4.3 stars.

9. Coco & Eve Sunny Honey Bali Bronzing Foam

Since all the tanners on this list do not give orange coloration, we won’t dwell much on that here. This tanner is meant to give all skin tones. Apart from giving you a natural-looking tan, the product has a dimension of 7.72 by 1.89 by 1.89 inches, and a weight of 6.35 ounces.

Since it contains a lot of antioxidants, the tanner will keep skin aging at bay. While testing it, the foam was easy to apply and it never transferred to any cloth. In addition, it smoothens, soothes, and revitalizes the skin. With the product, you’ll never end up with streaks and blotches. And it doesn’t give off any offensive odor.

Furthermore, it is cruelty-free and as such, it is vegan friendly. To sum it up, its Amazon rating of 4.4 stars says it all.

10. Bondi Sands Everyday Gradual Tanning Milk

We love the special application mitt that comes with this tanner. It is designed to absorb only the required quantity of tanner. With the mitt, you cannot apply too much tanner to your skin. Some of the tanner’s ingredients are Argan oil, Aloe Vera, Coconut oil, and Caramel.

You’ll get all skin tones from this tanner.

The product comes with a dimension of 7.8 by 5.25 by 1.5 inches, and it weighs 10.24 ounces. As long as you leave it to dry up, it will never leave any stain on your clothes. Furthermore, it leaves no streaks, blotches, or odor. If you apply it properly, it will last for up to 6 days before it begins to fade up. The product has an Amazon rating of 4.3 stars.

Do All Fake Tans Look Orange?

No, not all fake tans look orange. The orange look occurs for two reasons. First, if you apply a self-tanner to dry skin or dry part of your body, it is likely to turn orange. This is why we always advise our readers to moisturize their skin regularly before and after the application of a self-tanner.

Another cause of the orange look is the application of a tanner to areas of the body with thinner skin like the elbows, knees, hands, and feet without applying a lotion first. The emergence of orange patches on your body won’t harm you, but it will give you away as someone who applied a self-tanner.

To avoid orange coloration, you can do any of the three below:

  • Purchase a self-tanner that will never cause orange coloration like the ones reviewed here.
  • Moisturize your skin properly before you apply a self-tanner.
  • Apply some lotion to your hands, elbows, knees, and feet before you apply your self-tanner to the areas.

How To Get Rid Of Orange Self-Tanner?

There are products called fake tan removers. You can purchase one of them and apply it to your skin to remove the orange look. You can also use any of the methods below.

  • You can mix water with baking soda. Soak a piece of cloth in the solution, and rub the wet piece of clothes all over your body to remove all the tanner.
  • Alternatively, you can use white vinegar solution the same way.
  • You may also replace the baking soda solution with toothpaste.

What Self-Tanner Doesn’t Make Your Skin Orange?

There are several self-tanners that will never make your skin go orange. We have presented you with 10 of them in this article. In other words, all the self-tanners reviewed above will never lead to orange coloration regardless of how you apply them. And if you already have a self-tanner, you can adopt any of the methods listed above to prevent orange skin.

Is Orange Color Harmful To The Skin?

No, the orange color is not harmful to the skin in any way. Naturally, it will fade away in a matter of days. Since it is not harmful, you may want to know why people dread it. Generally, people admire natural tan. This is why people who use a self-tanner give the impression that their tan is natural.

Natural tans don’t yield orange coloration. Only fake tans do. Once people notice the orange patches on your body, it will be obvious that your tan is fake. Nothing can be as embarrassing as that. In other words, the orange color isn’t harmful, but it is embarrassing. So, try your best to avoid it.

If I Choose Any One Of The Self-Tanners Reviewed Above, Can I Still Get Orange Skin?

Absolutely not! We introduced them to you because they will never give any orange skin regardless of how you apply them to your skin. Once you pick any of them, you will no longer have to worry about having orange patches or streaks on your body.

Best Non Orange Self-Tanners

Final Verdict

Here’s our verdict. All the 10 self-tanners reviewed above are the best non orange self-tanners around. We tested all of them ourselves, and we stand by the reviews. Apart from not giving orange streaks, they don’t give off any odor, and they dry fast. In addition to giving you a natural-looking tan, they’ll also moisturize your skin. So, we hereby recommend all of them.

Leave a Comment